
Capacity is only half the story
Published in Coffs Coast News of the Area on 20 November 2026.
Dorothy, aged 93, passes away leaving an estate worth $3.3 million, comprising her home, shares and savings.
Dorothy has no children and has lived alone since the death of her partner, Robert.
Her earlier wills consistently benefit close friends and longstanding charities.
As Dorothy's health deteriorates, she relies on her friend, Helen. The two have known each other for 30 years, often attending charity luncheons together.
Dorothy suffers from advanced glaucoma, leaving her legally blind. Helen drives her to appointments, reads correspondence and prepares cheques for charities.
Sadly, Helen passes away, leaving Dorothy without her support.
Robert's son, Garrett, takes over with Dorothy's care and finances following several hospital admissions.
Dorothy subsequently expresses her intention to leave her home to Garrett.
Garrett contacts a solicitor to prepare a new will. The draft appoints Garrett sole executor and beneficiary of her entire estate, excluding all her friends and charities previously named as beneficiaries.
The solicitor prepares the will without speaking to Dorothy or confirming her instructions.
Garrett arranges for two acquaintances to witness Dorothy signing the will at her aged care facility. Neither had met her before, and one reads the document aloud before she signs.
Following Dorothy's death, the charities named in her previous will challenge Garrett's application for probate, questioning whether Dorothy knew and approved its contents.
The dispute reaches the Supreme Court, which finds that Dorothy possessed testamentary capacity.
However, her intention to leave Garrett her home does not establish that she knew and approved a will leaving him her entire estate.
The Court finds insufficient evidence of undue influence. However, the solicitor's failure to obtain Dorothy's instructions, together with the absence of evidence that she intended to leave Garrett her entire estate, leaves the Court unsatisfied that she knew and approved the will's contents.
Ultimately, the new will is invalid and Dorothy's earlier will takes effect.
Thank you to Ellysha Laklem for her assistance with this column.
If you have a request for a Hypothetical, call Manny Wood on (02) 66 487 487 or email [email protected].
This fictional column is not legal advice.



